2020 was the year that UK Government Debt interest surpassed Education spending
| Category | Amount (£ billion) |
|---|---|
| Debt Interest | £100 billion |
| Education | £82 billion |
<table>
<thead>
<tr>
<th>Factor</th>
<th>Effect</th>
</tr>
</thead>
<tbody>
<tr><td>Drop in consumption</td><td>-£8–£9B</td></tr>
<tr><td>Multiplier effect (est. 1.2x)</td><td>Total GDP ↓ ~<strong>£12 billion</strong></td></tr>
<tr><td>% of UK GDP</td><td>~<strong>0.5% reduction</strong></td></tr>
<tr><td>Business response</td><td>Reduced demand, less hiring</td></tr>
<tr><td>Regional inequality</td><td>Likely worsens</td></tr>
<tr><td>Long-term productivity</td><td>Depends on policy design & reallocation</td></tr>
</tbody>
</table>Based on the illustrative dataset used in the graph:
???? Estimated UK Government Spending in 2024
Taking away £10 billion in welfare payments from low-paid people would have a negative short-term effect on the economy, particularly on GDP, due to a drop in consumption.
Here’s a breakdown of the key effects:
???? 1. Immediate Drop in Consumption
Low-income households tend to spend nearly all their income (high marginal propensity to consume). Taking away £10 billion from them means:
- £8–£9 billion (or more) of consumer spending disappears
- Particularly affects sectors like food, energy, transport, and local retail
- Knock-on effect on businesses → less revenue → fewer jobs or hours
???? 2. GDP Decrease via the Multiplier Effect
GDP = C + I + G + (X – M)
This cut reduces both C (Consumption) and G (Government spending).
Multiplier effect: welfare spending typically has a fiscal multiplier of 1.2 to 1.5 because it’s highly targeted and quickly spent.
So:
GDP reduction ≈ £10B × 1.2 = £12B
If UK GDP is about £2.5 trillion, that’s a hit of:
£12B / £2.5T = ~0.5% of GDP
???? 3. Sectoral and Regional Effects
- Local economies (especially in lower-income areas) may contract more
- Businesses serving low-income households are hit hardest
- Possible increase in unemployment and social instability
????️ 4. No Automatic Offset
Unless that £10B is:
- Reallocated to high-multiplier spending (like infrastructure), or
- Given as targeted tax cuts to lower earners (also high MPC)
…it will likely reduce total demand and drag GDP down in the short run.
⚠️ 5. Long-Term Effects
Depends on what replaces the spending:
- If savings go to debt repayment, long-term stability might improve — but this has no immediate stimulus
- If cuts reduce work disincentives (in theory), labour participation might rise — but only gradually
✅ Summary: Estimated GDP Impact
| Factor | Effect |
|---|---|
| Drop in consumption | -£8–£9B |
| Multiplier effect (est. 1.2x) | Total GDP ↓ ~£12 billion |
| % of UK GDP | ~0.5% reduction |
| Business response | Reduced demand, less hiring |
| Regional inequality | Likely worsens |
| Long-term productivity | Depends on policy design & reallocation |
Would you like to compare this with cutting £10B from pensions, or spending the £10B on infrastructure to see alternative economic effects?
Discover more from Priory House
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.